Civil War

Sargepug

Sargepug

.40 S&W
Messages
102
Reaction score
83
Location
Westchester
So how does one fight this time? There is no "Mason Dixon Line", which in hindsight, I wish the South won! It will be neighbor to neighbor at this point.
I seriously think there needs to be a military coup, to put Trump in office, as the end all.
 
US RIFLE M1A

US RIFLE M1A

.45 acp
Messages
362
Reaction score
886
Location
PA/NY Border in NEPA
As Shelby Foote noted in Ken Burns' civil war documentary, the conflict between the states that we refer to as The Civil War (1860-1865) - that war created a nation in which a conflict such as that is, today, inconceivable. We will never have another civil war like the first one (although the Revolution was a civil war to some extent, making the Civil War the second one in actuality.)

If you are interested in seeing what an American de-evolution into violence will look like, see any major riot in America over the past almost 250 years. That is actually more in character for us than the blue and gray were.

Study in particular the draft riots in NYC in 1863 (Civil War troops actually had to be called on their way home to help) the race riots of the 1960s, Rodney King, George Floyd, etc.

In order to destroy a perceived enemy that is at home and up close, the American character requires a cause that effects the people personally. Be it fear of being drafted, racial inequality, or what they perceive as police brutality, they need to be personal issues.

And the destruction will be local. It may be widespread, but the participants will lash out on whatever is physically closest to them.

There are many entities that wish for another full-blown civil war here in America, many nations, and not too few of our own in leadership positions, many of whom would love to swoop in and crush our rights.

But they have it wrong.

Entirely wrong.

Most Americans, the ones that actually could participate in a good, old fashioned Civil War - training, equipment, etc. - they will be the ones who, quietly and peacefully stand fast and keep the rest of the nation functioning as the centers of violence implode.
 
Last edited:
Grimscale

Grimscale

.338 Win Mag
Messages
8,603
Reaction score
16,852
Location
Rochester
Sargepug said:
So how does one fight this time? There is no "Mason Dixon Line",
Click to expand...
Initially, at least, you'll see one side go absolutely ape-shit, burning their own neighborhoods to the ground and trying to get as much "free shit" as possible, while the other side is quietly and methodically targeting those they believe were the cause of the downfall.
I would not want to be a politician during that time period. Specifically not one who had been advocating for mass unregulated immigration, massive subsidies of non-working individuals, and graft.

Eventually the ape-shits will try to organize, but by then it will be too late.
 
Cooolone

Cooolone

.338 Win Mag
Messages
6,387
Reaction score
9,949
Location
NY, USA
Civil unrest, rioting and the lot, is not to be confused with a "Civil" war...

The Civil War we had here wasn't all about slavery as it would be made. It was considered by the one side "Northern Aggression" to enforce power by one side over the other. Political Will which once refused led to armed conflict, and the individual chosing to get involved to protect their own home(s) and land...

Thinking the foot soldier was involved in politics or whatnot is ridiculous... It was about an evil entity invading by force and wanting to institute control.

What could be more different today?

Are not contemporary issues providing contrast betweens States ideologies? Have some expressed their disdain for the heavy Federal Govt wanting to enforce control over their sovereign rights? The undercurrent is there... Certainly today, and building.

But historically, civil war usually has occured once all power has been removed from one side... When those aligned with the losing side have lost all and see no future ahead. Left with little choice, they fight back. We aren't talking about taking away Sunday dinner, or TV... And there's a difference! Question is...

If the election appears to be a sham... Will States react? Not individuals, not organizations, but States! Would they chose to make a statement and take a stand that they would remove themselves from the Union of States?

Remember, there is nothing in our Constitution or other laws which paint the path for separation, only how to join the Union... And Texas's argument in the 1880's was shot down (pun intended) by the SCOTUS back then... Basically saying what I laid out above.

A real civil war vs the collective States that would seek to separate would be interesting... It would require those states to have industrial capability, financial reserves and at least at some level, foreign support because once the bullets fly, they'll need it!

Are we there yet? Anywhere near?

IMO not a snowballs chance in hell are we anywhere near the simmering pit that would be needed waiting for a spark to ignite such a thing... All the powers that be are busy infighting right now and politicians are mostly engaged with self preservation the minute they get elected... There's not many who outwardly project to be genuinely concerned about their constituents, or their lives, or their State's Sovereignty!!!

Just thoughts...
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
38,572
Reaction score
42,975
Location
Western NY
I’m not even sure how to respond to this. OP wants a military coup to install a leader/dictator in the USA? That sounds like something I’d be willing to fight against not for. The constitution has served this county well for many years and there’s nothing in there about that. The problem is we are getting away from the constitution and no one is fighting to get back there. Yea there are plenty of other problems and I think Trump is the better candidate but he’s an egotistical nut and doesn’t need endless power or time in office to get worse.
 
M

ManualF150

.308 Win
Messages
4,836
Reaction score
8,835
Location
Cayuga
I keep hearing more and more about this summer might be worse than summer of 2020 with the pandemic with people going all out loony.

Heck, look at what a few feet of snow did to folks out my way here in Buffalo region -- looting stores, shootings, etc. Over a few feet of snow. :idk:

People also seem more off than usual too. Like they can't be trusted.
 
Sargepug

Sargepug

.40 S&W
Messages
102
Reaction score
83
Location
Westchester
Grimscale said:
Initially, at least, you'll see one side go absolutely ape-shit, burning their own neighborhoods to the ground and trying to get as much "free shit" as possible, while the other side is quietly and methodically targeting those they believe were the cause of the downfall.
I would not want to be a politician during that time period. Specifically not one who had been advocating for mass unregulated immigration, massive subsidies of non-working individuals, and graft.

Eventually the ape-shits will try to organize, but by then it will be too late.
Click to expand...
Well get ready for it, cause the steal will take place again this year and then war........
 
Sargepug

Sargepug

.40 S&W
Messages
102
Reaction score
83
Location
Westchester
Saltwater60 said:
I’m not even sure how to respond to this. OP wants a military coup to install a leader/dictator in the USA? That sounds like something I’d be willing to fight against not for. The constitution has served this county well for many years and there’s nothing in there about that. The problem is we are getting away from the constitution and no one is fighting to get back there. Yea there are plenty of other problems and I think Trump is the better candidate but he’s an egotistical nut and doesn’t need endless power or time in office to get worse.
Click to expand...
Constitution is under attack! Once the '20 election was stolen , all gloves are off. It will be solen once again this year! Yes, IMO the only way to get this country back on track, is to have a coup and put Trump where he rightfully belongs.
The line has been crossed, the empire is falling and harsh maneuvers are paramount!
 
W

Willyone

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
2,158
Reaction score
3,982
Location
Elbridge, NY
Sargepug said:
Constitution is under attack! Once the '20 election was stolen , all gloves are off. It will be solen once again this year! Yes, IMO the only way to get this country back on track, is to have a coup and put Trump where he rightfully belongs.
The line has been crossed, the empire is falling and harsh maneuvers are paramount!
Click to expand...

Sure... "a coup to put Trump where he rightfully belongs"... a coup?? Please describe the coup you mention, the details, the plan? You know, the thing...
 
Sargepug

Sargepug

.40 S&W
Messages
102
Reaction score
83
Location
Westchester
Willyone said:
Sure... "a coup to put Trump where he rightfully belongs"... a coup?? Please describe the coup you mention, the details, the plan? You know, the thing...
Click to expand...
ok, all of our troops in all the arms of our military, have to unite w/ all the police forces in the country. Then advance on DC and do what needs to be done. It's that simple. This country is collapsing, I'm turning 54 and I don't recognize it anymore, I didn't grow up in this horror. Yes, it started in the 60s w/ the hippies about Nam and then rotten women's lib (another travesty), but it wasn't accepted as mainstream, like all of the horrors of today.
 
Kwalsh

Kwalsh

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
1,665
Reaction score
2,009
Location
Cohoes
Seems like a pretty spirited thread for a fairly new member, maybe when big brother reads this they should “ put him on their radar”
 
repete

repete

.338 Win Mag
Messages
6,333
Reaction score
9,588
Location
Rochester NY
Sargepug said:
ok, all of our troops in all the arms of our military, have to unite w/ all the police forces in the country. Then advance on DC and do what needs to be done. It's that simple. This country is collapsing, I'm turning 54 and I don't recognize it anymore, I didn't grow up in this horror. Yes, it started in the 60s w/ the hippies about Nam and then rotten women's lib (another travesty), but it wasn't accepted as mainstream, like all of the horrors of today.
Click to expand...
Please go on, especially about ALL the troops AND LEO's uniting! I haven't laughed this hard in a long time!
Where do you see YOU in all this?
 
Clancy

Clancy

.45 acp
Messages
258
Reaction score
503
Location
12787
"all of our troops in all the arms of our military, have to unite w/ all the police forces in the country."

Can you provide any examples of our military to fire on civilians? Can you provide any examples of our police refusing to enforce laws unless ordered not to by their leaders?

Conversation with you over dinner must be fascinating.
 
spat

spat

.950 JDJ
Messages
32,155
Reaction score
68,198
Location
Formerly Geneseo, NY. Now free in AZ
Grimscale said:
Initially, at least, you'll see one side go absolutely ape-shit, burning their own neighborhoods to the ground and trying to get as much "free shit" as possible, while the other side is quietly and methodically targeting those they believe were the cause of the downfall.
I would not want to be a politician during that time period. Specifically not one who had been advocating for mass unregulated immigration, massive subsidies of non-working individuals, and graft.

Eventually the ape-shits will try to organize, but by then it will be too late.
Click to expand...
I see it going French revolution style.

The leftists have indoctrinated their base into a frenzied hatred of anyone with more than them, the elites will be hunted by their own supporters.

If the right plays their cards right, you let the ANTIFA and BLM crowd destroy the ruling class, then play off their divisions to take over.

That is a big if.
 
Z

Zerex

.308 Win
Messages
3,777
Reaction score
2,839
Location
Rome, NY
We have no leaders...................they have no leaders.................orneryness is at an all time high.

Commies vs Capitalists,
women vs men
black vs white
LBGTQ vs straights

CCP against us all.........

A Military coup by old guard Military and old guard Deep Staters to preserve the Republic from the CCP........possible...........keeps the Nuke Option open, and a hard ass Gov't running.

Arrests of commie judges, politicians, governors, mayors, senators, reps of all stripes..they would have a list to be sent to Gitmo and disappear....say 5000 inc MSM

Local militias would be authorized to keep the peace by keeping green and eco-terrorist student commies down.

Love conquers all..love of the Republic minus commies...... that is.
 
W

Willyone

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
2,158
Reaction score
3,982
Location
Elbridge, NY
Sargepug said:
ok, all of our troops in all the arms of our military, have to unite w/ all the police forces in the country. Then advance on DC and do what needs to be done. It's that simple. This country is collapsing, I'm turning 54 and I don't recognize it anymore, I didn't grow up in this horror. Yes, it started in the 60s w/ the hippies about Nam and then rotten women's lib (another travesty), but it wasn't accepted as mainstream, like all of the horrors of today.
Click to expand...

Well fuck'n A, we all love a good party. Have your people contact my people with the when and where info and I'll have my well hidden underground stored F-15s fueled and at the ready. Can't wait:rock:
 
Robin

Robin

.577 Tyrannosaur.
Messages
21,903
Reaction score
48,256
Location
Livingston County
Sargepug said:
ok, all of our troops in all the arms of our military, have to unite w/ all the police forces in the country. Then advance on DC and do what needs to be done. It's that simple. This country is collapsing, I'm turning 54 and I don't recognize it anymore, I didn't grow up in this horror. Yes, it started in the 60s w/ the hippies about Nam and then rotten women's lib (another travesty), but it wasn't accepted as mainstream, like all of the horrors of today.
Click to expand...
Well sarge, you lead the way.
We're waiting.
Robin
 
W

Willyone

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
2,158
Reaction score
3,982
Location
Elbridge, NY
We'll need to come up with a pithy name for this band of merry men.... a name noted with 3 letter acronym. Preferably one that is not already taken, being used :cool:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top