Paul Harrell videos
- Thread starter S&W Fan
- Start date
Eddie Gunks
.338 Win Mag
Ha ha ha.
6:15 and 7:47 are funny.
Taurus judge,” just malfunctions”
“If you are sleeping with this gun, you are pobably sleeping alone!”
Ha ha ha
6:15 and 7:47 are funny.
Taurus judge,” just malfunctions”
“If you are sleeping with this gun, you are pobably sleeping alone!”
Ha ha ha
Who the hell is shooting from under their covers?
I guess im just used to having dogs, I will know someone is in our home long before I see them.
I will have time to put my shoes on, turn on the lights, decide which gun to use.............
I guess im just used to having dogs, I will know someone is in our home long before I see them.
I will have time to put my shoes on, turn on the lights, decide which gun to use.............
Plenty of time to call 911 and wait for the boys in blue then eh?
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
I watch his videos. I think he skews the results by going with the heaviest for caliber on what he likes and going for the lightest for caliber on what he doesn't like but I still watch his videos for informational purposes regardless.
Ive never even seen a cop around here.
It would be 20 minutes before they reach here.
Cops around here welcome the help taking out the bad guys.
Im saying nobody is sneaking in my room making me do something as stupid as shooting from under the covers.
I cant think of much more dangerous or dumb as sleeping with a loaded gun under your covers while you sleep.
Accepting a drink from Bill Cosby?
I wonder if he ever spiked any pudding pops????
I like pudding pops.
Yeah, I get it. It was a tounge in cheek comment. However, if you watched the video and listened to the commentary you would know that he did the experiment based on a question posed by a viewer. He wasn’t advocating one way or another.
Acer-m14
20×102mm Vulcan
i figure the auto under cover would have issues .. you need a space pocket to eject the spent round or you got a stove pipe ..
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
Who the hell shoots from under the covers? Fail!
I'm sorry but that is ridiculous. First you would have to identify what his supposed likes are and correlatenthat to his ammo selection which would be flawed in itself since, for whatever reason, he relies on brick and mortar stores which have limited choices in selection.
Then there is the fact that heavy for caliber ammunition is not necessarily the best performing choice. In 9mm for example the 124gr is on par or better than the other weights.
.............Um is that an invitation?
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
If you watch all his videos, he clearly says that .40 is superior.
And if you are gonna shoot cinder blocks with FMJ, heavy for caliber does better. If you are going to use heavy for. 40, use heavy for 9mm. It also helps if you shoot them in the same place. This is a guy that can put 2 or 3 shots in one hole. The .40's were all in one place and the 9mm's were shot in different places.
If you are going to do videos for profit, there should be no excuse for not getting the right ammo. Don't use a quality hollow point in .40 and compare it to 115gr hollow point in 9mm from Walmart.
In that one video I posted, it pained him to admit that the Xtreme Penetrator did better than the hollow point though the car door. In his previous video, he used the 9mm Penetrator with the meat targets. He said that it did well but it penetrated too much. Than he tried the car door with the meat targets but with .40 thinking that the heavier hollow point would do better. It didn't. He should have stuck with 9mm for the test to keep things consistent but he knew the 9mm 115 gr hollow point he always uses wouldn't do well against the car door so he tried it in .40 hoping that the extra weight would do better.
Like I said, I don't hate the guy. I still watch his videos. But he isn't fair when comparing 2 things.
Last edited:
Of the three big defensive calibers the .40 is superior, in terms of energy anyway.
You are still reading way too much into his ammo selection. Once again such seems to driven by availability as much as anything.
You are focusing on minutiae at the expense of missing the point. None of his videos are to be taken as the definitive, end all say, a point Paul repeatedly belabors in his videos. He is simply putting out data and he does it using unique parameters and methods you don't see elsewhere.
Also while my personal preference in firearms tends very much to the modern and "tactical" side of things I think its refreshing and if value that in his vidoes Paul showcases things like revolvers and lever guns quite often as these ate the tupes of guns that are universally accessible in this country and yet are very often overlooked when we are talking about self defense.
I also enjoy his dry, sardonic delivery and he doesn't take himself too seriously.
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
Everything else is cool. It isn't minute to me when comparing ammo and then at the end of the video saying that one is better than the other.
If I used a 45gr .223 instead of using a 77 gr against a .300 Blackout, I can say that the .300 does better at long distance.
That's a flawed comparison to begin with regardless of bullet weights. This highlights my point that maybe you are looking at these videos in the wrong way.
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
Am I going to have to post the video and do a play by play? Lol. It's late man.
I'm afraid you might have to because I'm just not seeing it the way you are.
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
Tomorrow.
gun_slinger_boy
.338 Win Mag
Well wouldn't that be true? That would be objective facts not subjective opinion. From the videos I've seen he always tries to match up the ammo and guns as closely as possible. Down to the barrel length and brand of ammo. How many horrible videos do we see where a guy tests 45ACP vs 9mm and then uses a 5 inch 45ACP ball vs a 3 inch 9mm hollow point? Then goes on to say how one is better at smashing through a cinder block much better than another. And at the end of the day the data is totally useless anyhow because everyone knows 45ACP is better than 9mm.
Marine Cpl
.577 Tyrannosaur.
I already took an Ambien. Lol
libertysnake
.338 Win Mag
I keep watching on the pretense that one time, maybe just one time, I'll hear him say. "And that's why this is one riddle you just can't solve, Batman" in that sort of Riddler voice he's got going on.
Bob
6.5 Creedmoor
Yep. Been subscribed to him for a long time. His is one of the few channels that I recommend. I don't always agree with his conclusions, but he is usually fairly consistent and well thought-out.
gun_slinger_boy
.338 Win Mag
I could only imagine the look on the face of the range officer that came upon this. He would probably just turn around and walk away without saying a word.