Brawny71's latest activity
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Accessing Private Property to track or retrieve game.S 140.10 Criminal trespass in the third degree. A person is guilty of criminal trespass in the third degree when he knowingly enters or... -
Brawny71 replied to the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting.Justification is spelled out above for dwelling. S 140.00 Criminal trespass and burglary; definitions of terms. The following...
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Accessing Private Property to track or retrieve game.https://www.nrawomen.com/content/hunting-dilemma-when-the-deer-crosses-the-property-line
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Accessing Private Property to track or retrieve game.https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/PEN/140.05
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Accessing Private Property to track or retrieve game.Penal Law Section 140.05 Trespass A person is guilty of trespass when he knowingly enters or remains unlawfully in or upon premises...
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting.Also physical vs. deadly force becomes a whole other mud fight. In the thread example I didn’t hear anything about weapons. Shooting...
-
Brawny71 reacted to Saltwater60's post in the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting with
Like.
I’d argue almost every county in NYS you’d be charged for shooting someone in your attached garage. I’d also need to see some sort of... -
Brawny71 replied to the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting.This has the dwelling reference as posted above. But note the justification reiterated. S 35.15 Justification; use of physical force...
-
Brawny71 reacted to spat's post in the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting with Like.
That depends greatly on what county you live in. The laws may be identical, but the application varies drastically. Which is a sign of...
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting.NYS PENAL 35 S 35.05 Justification; generally. Unless otherwise limited by the ensuing provisions of this article defining...
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting.Agree. Discussion which continues. Several judges interpret (no solid case law established) it differently within the state. Due...
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting.In NYS, you still have a duty to retreat until no longer safe to do so depending on situation. Even in your castle. No saying I fully...
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting.Correct….. but only after Duty to Retreat and Justification have been met. Each state defines each differently. Also why I poster the...
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting.Also hard to verify imminent threat thru a closed door with no window.
-
Brawny71 replied to the thread Good shoot? Manslaughter charges brought in Michigan garage burglary shooting.A lot of variables. They do have Castle Doctrine but I’m still looking for their definition. Justification is also hard to find in...