Off duty Buffalo Police Officer Shoots a German Shepherd Diring an Attack

Saltwater60

Saltwater60

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
37,749
Reaction score
42,088
Location
Western NY
I find it hilarious how people are up in arms about this and wondering why the police officer had his gun on him. I have mine on me when I walk my neighborhood. Of course the idiot who lost control of her two huge dogs is t to blame by any of them and the news doesn’t speak to the laws about that. It’s all bad cop.
I find him fully justified. I’m sad the dog died because of the owners neglect but it’s not the cops fault. In fact she should be ticketed.
 
F

fresch

.338 Win Mag
Messages
9,047
Reaction score
11,956
Location
Syracuse
"Never off duty", protected class, could a pleb get away doing this or is it jail time?
 
OwnTheRide

OwnTheRide

.223 Rem
Messages
1,483
Reaction score
2,996
Location
Allegany
One hundred percent, she should have kept control of her dogs.

But, watch the footage, and in particular the body language of the GSDs. Those dogs were not attacking. Charging, barking, yes... but not attacking. I'll give you that we can't expect everyone to be able to read dogs as easily as I do.

I'm not willing to call this a good shoot, but I'm also not willing to call it a bad shoot. It's unfortunate all around. I wish the officer had read the situation better, but the owner definitely should have had better control of her dogs. And I do think the negligent owner's point about when the officer chose to shoot is valid. She really was right there and in the line of fire. He's very lucky she didn't get hit.

So in the end, I arrive at the same point as Salt, but without the same reasoning. No charges for officer, ticket for negligent owner.

Since I'm playing MMQB, what would I have done? Simple: either picked up the little dog, or gotten between the little dog and the GSDs. I can easily control two large unknown dogs (who aren't specifically trained to attack, such as police dogs) using presence, voice, body language, or in extreme circumstances, a swift kick. But I recognize not everyone can, nor do I think that should that be an expectation.
 
Drinkthekoolaid

Drinkthekoolaid

.475 A&M Magnum
U.S. Military
Messages
16,958
Reaction score
30,221
Location
Unfortunately, NY
I don't have time to read the story/ watch the video

Did the off duty officer who is essentially acting like any regular citizen out for a walk get bit before he shot the dog?

That's all I need to know to make my opinion.

If he was bitten, then he acted in self defense.
If he was not bitten then his actions are right to be scrutinized.

I am making my opinions based on what I would do if I'm out taking a walk carrying my pistol. If a dog runs up and is barking at me and acting threatening but not actually biting me I know if I shot it i would be arrested. So that's my standard of judgment for this off duty cop.
 
tirwin1

tirwin1

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
19,221
Reaction score
53,241
Location
rochester
To hell with the owner of the german shepards. She "lost control". In my mind, as a former dog owner, she is a horrible owner. Period. If you can't handle your two dogs in public that is entirely your fault.

The poor dog that was being attacked could easily have been mauled to death by those two dogs. I don't blame the off duty cop for a second.

I have owned dogs and I have been bitten by dogs. I have zero sympathy for this woman or any dog owner that can't control their dogs. Go to hell lady.
 
spat

spat

.950 JDJ
Messages
31,125
Reaction score
66,054
Location
Formerly Geneseo, NY. Now free in AZ
What if the woman with the dogs was legally armed ?

You're out walking your dogs and some guy draws his gun and shoots one of them for barking at him. Sounds like she'd be in a reasonable fear that she might be next.

If she'd shot him dead on the spot, would that be justified?

He didn't get bit. I think if I was on that jury she'd walk.
 
tirwin1

tirwin1

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
19,221
Reaction score
53,241
Location
rochester
spat said:
What if the woman with the dogs was legally armed ?

You're out walking your dogs and some guy draws his gun and shoots one of them for barking at him. Sounds like she'd be in a reasonable fear that she might be next.

If she'd shot him dead on the spot, would that be justified?

He didn't get bit. I think if I was on that jury she'd walk.
Click to expand...
Except they weren't barking. They were attacking. A rather significant difference I would say.
 
S&W Fan

S&W Fan

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
15,685
Reaction score
23,180
Location
Onondaga
Drinkthekoolaid said:
I don't have time to read the story/ watch the video

Did the off duty officer who is essentially acting like any regular citizen out for a walk get bit before he shot the dog?

That's all I need to know to make my opinion.

If he was bitten, then he acted in self defense.
If he was not bitten then his actions are right to be scrutinized.

I am making my opinions based on what I would do if I'm out taking a walk carrying my pistol. If a dog runs up and is barking at me and acting threatening but not actually biting me I know if I shot it i would be arrested. So that's my standard of judgment for this off duty cop.
Click to expand...
If you wait to be bitten by a dog, in this case potentially two dogs at which point they Would be attacking you , your chances of getting to your firearm are drastically reduced. I won’t voice an opinion because I can't get the footage to play. However, some here are attributing human behaviors to animals, that’s dangerously wrong.
 
Drinkthekoolaid

Drinkthekoolaid

.475 A&M Magnum
U.S. Military
Messages
16,958
Reaction score
30,221
Location
Unfortunately, NY
S&W Fan said:
If you wait to be bitten by a dog, in this case potentially two dogs at which point they Would be attacking you , your chances of getting to your firearm are drastically reduced. I won’t voice an opinion because I can't get the footage to play. However, some here are attributing human behaviors to animals, that’s dangerously wrong.
Click to expand...

I don't necessarily disagree, however...

If I'm walking in my neighborhood, and 2 "off leash" dogs are acting aggressively, and I shoot them without being bitten, I'm going to get charged and end up in Court/jail.

Why is it too much to hold the off duty cop to the same standards and limitations? His life and safety are no more valuable than mine is to me.

I judge others and make my opinions based on what I would do in that situation.
 
spat

spat

.950 JDJ
Messages
31,125
Reaction score
66,054
Location
Formerly Geneseo, NY. Now free in AZ
S&W Fan said:
If you wait to be bitten by a dog, in this case potentially two dogs at which point they Would be attacking you , your chances of getting to your firearm are drastically reduced. I won’t voice an opinion because I can't get the footage to play. However, some here are attributing human behaviors to animals, that’s dangerously wrong.
Click to expand...
Nobody would fault him for drawing. If you already have your gun drawn and in your hand, then yea, you can absolutely deploy it if bitten.

Sounds like the dogs weren't even threatening *him*, just his dog.
 
tirwin1

tirwin1

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
19,221
Reaction score
53,241
Location
rochester
spat said:
Were they attacking ? Doesn't seem like it to me.

Running at someone and barking doesn’t constitute an attack anymore than yelling at someone does.
Click to expand...
I viewed it as an attack. That little dog stood little chance against the 2 German shepherds.
 
repete

repete

.338 Win Mag
Messages
6,300
Reaction score
9,515
Location
Rochester NY
Couldn't see the vid, but " Why did he have his gun on him in the first place?” Just in case he was attacked by dogs or something that why!
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
37,749
Reaction score
42,088
Location
Western NY
spat said:
What if the woman with the dogs was legally armed ?

You're out walking your dogs and some guy draws his gun and shoots one of them for barking at him. Sounds like she'd be in a reasonable fear that she might be next.

If she'd shot him dead on the spot, would that be justified?

He didn't get bit. I think if I was on that jury she'd walk.
Click to expand...
Interesting thought. Was she the original aggressor?
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
37,749
Reaction score
42,088
Location
Western NY
spat said:
Nobody would fault him for drawing. If you already have your gun drawn and in your hand, then yea, you can absolutely deploy it if bitten.

Sounds like the dogs weren't even threatening *him*, just his dog.
Click to expand...
I’m sure there are plenty who would fault him. The people in the article don’t think he should have even had a gun on him while walking.
 
OwnTheRide

OwnTheRide

.223 Rem
Messages
1,483
Reaction score
2,996
Location
Allegany
GOPerfect said:
Yes. I know this for a fact. A personal fact.
Click to expand...
Agreed that a non-cop could get out of this situation without charges, though I think a cop is more likely to.

Also, I can't help but notice a few things that potentially indicate preferential treatment:

1. He wasn't arrested
2. His guns were not taken
3. His name has not been released

That said, those three things are the right move... they just should apply to everyone.
 
Last edited:
GOPerfect

GOPerfect

.950 JDJ
U.S. Military
Messages
33,709
Reaction score
77,432
Location
No longer Secret, thanks DR. Evil
OwnTheRide said:
Agreed that a non-cop could get out of this situation without charges, though I think a cop is more likely to.

Also, I can't help but notice a few things that potentially indicate preferential treatment:

1. He wasn't arrested
2. His guns were not taken
3. His name has not been released

That said, those three things are the right move... they just just apply to everyone.
Click to expand...


I may or may not have been involved in something like this many years back.

I may have been just a regular guy.

There may not have been any arrests, confiscating and my name may have never been released.

All hypothetical though...
 
spat

spat

.950 JDJ
Messages
31,125
Reaction score
66,054
Location
Formerly Geneseo, NY. Now free in AZ
Saltwater60 said:
Interesting thought. Was she the original aggressor?
Click to expand...
I'm not convinced there *was* an attack for her or even her dogs to be the aggressor.

It's far more common for dogs to growl and charge and *not* actually attack than the other way around.

And it doesn't sound like he was even the target if the supposed attack, just his dog. Legally, all the dogs involved were just property. In NY do you get to draw and fire your gun just to prevent property damage ? Can you shoot someone's dog for stealing your lunch ?
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
37,749
Reaction score
42,088
Location
Western NY
spat said:
I'm not convinced there *was* an attack for her or even her dogs to be the aggressor.

It's far more common for dogs to growl and charge and *not* actually attack than the other way around.

And it doesn't sound like he was even the target if the supposed attack, just his dog. Legally, all the dogs involved were just property. In NY do you get to draw and fire your gun just to prevent property damage ? Can you shoot someone's dog for stealing your lunch ?
Click to expand...
That’s hard to say from the crappy quality video. I will say people do not seem to dispute the attack. I also do not think you would ever get this to be taken to trail over the dog is just property. Legally speaking g you’re correct but all it would take is for the officer to say this is how I’m trained on the job or a law hit me or I feared for my life. Is there anything legally speaking that says you have to be attacked to go to deadly physical force? What if the officer said the lady was running over to get in the middle of it and I feared for her life or after the dogs attacked and killed my dog I feared for my life or the person across the streets life? To me they are all valid situations and arguments. If I was on the jury I would not convict the officer.
I’m just curious why hasn’t the women been handed some tickets yet? She won’t be for I guess obvious reasons but she clearly broke the law. I’d also wonder how many other incidents her dogs were involved in. I doubt this was the first one with her dog being 9 years old.
 
spat

spat

.950 JDJ
Messages
31,125
Reaction score
66,054
Location
Formerly Geneseo, NY. Now free in AZ
Keyzard said:
I take our dog for a couple mile walk every day, and having to deal with an aggressive animal is my biggest fear.
I really don't want to shoot someone's pet, so my pistol would be my last resort. I always carry pepper spray on those walks.
Click to expand...
We have a truly shocking number of dogs that just run loose out here. They're actual pets, not strays, but people seem very nonchalant about free ranging their dogs.

May have something to do with the open range laws and the fact that cattle and other livestock roam freely. If you don't want them eating your vegetable garden you need to fence them out.

We have a leash law, but it doesn't seem anyone really cares.

We also have many packs of wild coyotes running loose too.

I carry when we walk the dog, I carry anytime i'm wearing pants, but I would have to be in real fear of serious injury to shoot one, and that likely would mean already being injured and unable to stop them any other way.
 
Jmac00

Jmac00

.475 A&M Magnum
Messages
18,936
Reaction score
52,064
Location
somewhere in America
tirwin1 said:
To hell with the owner of the german shepards. She "lost control". In my mind, as a former dog owner, she is a horrible owner. Period. If you can't handle your two dogs in public that is entirely your fault.

The poor dog that was being attacked could easily have been mauled to death by those two dogs. I don't blame the off duty cop for a second.

I have owned dogs and I have been bitten by dogs. I have zero sympathy for this woman or any dog owner that can't control their dogs. Go to hell lady.
Click to expand...

I concur. I 'workamp' at a RV park. last year, a couple came in with two massive Great Danes, these boys were big even by Great Dane standards. They were walking around the campground and the husband had to take a leak, so he hands the dogs off to his 130-140 pound wife. He proceeds to the bathroom which was about 3 feet way. While the husband had control, the dogs were very well behaved, but he handed them off to the wife. The dogs see a squirrel <not kidding, a freak'n 13 stripe ground squirrel> and drags this poor lady down a paved street for about 15 feet. She got a pretty good case of road rash before the old man came out and regained control.
On the plus side, the nice lady never let go of the leads, but she, and I suspect the old man, were not very happy. She walked back to their camper alone :idk:

It's all in how the dogs are trained. If you can't walk them on a lead, by either guardian, then the dogs need a lot more training
 
GOPerfect

GOPerfect

.950 JDJ
U.S. Military
Messages
33,709
Reaction score
77,432
Location
No longer Secret, thanks DR. Evil
spat said:
We have a truly shocking number of dogs that just run loose out here. They're actual pets, not strays, but people seem very nonchalant about free ranging their dogs.

May have something to do with the open range laws and the fact that cattle and other livestock roam freely. If you don't want them eating your vegetable garden you need to fence them out.

We have a leash law, but it doesn't seem anyone really cares.

We also have many packs of wild coyotes running loose too.

I carry when we walk the dog, I carry anytime i'm wearing pants, but I would have to be in real fear of serious injury to shoot one, and that likely would mean already being injured and unable to stop them any other way.
Click to expand...


The free range dogs here... it is astounding how many there are.

I shoot at dogs on a near daily basis. I started with BB's. I am up to pellets now. If they do not start to learn, I will notch that up another level.
 
spat

spat

.950 JDJ
Messages
31,125
Reaction score
66,054
Location
Formerly Geneseo, NY. Now free in AZ
GOPerfect said:
The free range dogs here... it is astounding how many there are.

I shoot at dogs on a near daily basis. I started with BB's. I am up to pellets now. If they do not start to learn, I will notch that up another level.
Click to expand...
We had a problem when i was a kid with dogs getting into our garbage

The solution was simple. Put the metal cans on a rubber stall mat and hook an electric fencer up to them.

Only problem we had after that was forgetting to turn the fencer off before taking out the garbage LoL
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top