NYS Want To Block You From Asking AI Agents Questions.

[libertysnake]

​

Yogi

@Houseofyogi

New York wants to ban you from asking AI a question You're sitting on the bathroom floor at 11pm. Your kid is screaming. The rash is spreading up his arm. You're holding your phone with one hand and holding him with the other. You don't have insurance. You don't have $400 for a doctor. The urgent care closed an hour ago. You're Googling symptoms and getting ten different answers from ten sketchy websites. So you open Claude. You describe the rash. It tells you it's probably contact dermatitis. Try hydrocortisone cream tonight. See a doctor if it spreads or your kid gets a fever. Your hands stop shaking. You sleep. Kathy Hochul wants to take that away from you.

You're the dad who works 3 shifts. You come home and there's a paper taped to your door. You read it three times and still don't understand what it means. You have seven days. You call a lawyer. $317 an hour. You have $40 in your checking account and two kids asleep inside an apartment you might lose by Friday. You open AI. In ten seconds you find out the notice isn't even legal. It tells you your rights. It tells you what to file. It tells you what to say. New York wants to make that illegal.

You're the kid from the small town who left the farm for your first job in the city. Your employer puts a contract in front of you. Non-compete. Arbitration clause. Words you've never seen before. Your parents never signed anything like this. They worked with their hands. You ask AI to explain it in plain English. It does. For free. At midnight. New York wants to make that illegal too.

Senate Bill S7263. Bans AI from giving "substantive responses" about medicine, law, dentistry, nursing, psychology, social work, engineering, and more. Not banning AI from pretending to be your doctor. Not banning AI from writing prescriptions. Banning AI from answering your questions. North Korea controls what you can read. New York wants to control what you can ask.

So you have to go back to paying $317 an hour for a lawyer. $400 for a doctor visit. $200 for a therapist. Money you don't have. Money that goes right back into the pockets of the people who wrote this bill. Who does this actually hurt? It's not the guy on Park Avenue. He has a doctor on speed dial. He has a lawyer on retainer. He has a therapist he sees on Tuesdays. It's the single mom in the Bronx with no insurance and a sick kid at 11pm. It's the grandma who just got served papers she can't read. It's the first-gen college kid signing a contract nobody in his family has ever seen before.

For the first time, a single mom had access to the same information as the guy on Park Avenue. Not better care. Not a free lawyer. Just answers. Just enough to know what questions to ask. You want to know why? Follow the money. Any trial lawyer in New York can sue AI companies and collect fees when they win. It's a lawsuit printing press. $377 million was spent lobbying Albany last year. A record.

The healthcare lobby alone spent $11.5 million. Trial lawyer PACs pumped $4.7 million into New York politicians. Governor Hochul took over $545,000 from them personally. One company gave her office $300,000 in donations and got $400 million in Medicaid contracts back. Every $317/hour law firm that doesn't want you getting free answers. Every hospital billing $400 for a ten-minute visit. The entire industry that profits from keeping you confused. The lobbyists write the bill. The politicians file the bill. The lawyers profit from the bill. And the single mom in the Bronx loses the only help she could afford.

In the 1800s they called public libraries dangerous because poor people had unsupervised access to books. In 1910 they shut down Black medical schools to "protect patients." Every time the gates start to crack open for regular people, someone with a billing rate shows up to weld them shut. They want you poor and stupid. And they'll call it consumer protection. And the kid with the rash at 11pm? He goes back to ten sketchy websites and a mom who can't sleep. New York shouldn't be North Korea.

If this goes through, most people will simply VPN around it who can't leave. Tech companies will effectively leave NYS and it will destroy NYC's economy.

 

[libertysnake]

You can also run your own LLMs at home without any data being shipped off or scraped by meta, anthropic, and the like.

The Vulcan release of llama cpp works on any gpu. Releases · ggml-org/llama.cpp and there are even CPU only releases.

Pair that with models like QWEN 3.5 and you have a great AI setup that rivals anything from OpenAI or Anthropic.

unsloth/Qwen3.5-35B-A3B-GGUF · Hugging Face

We’re on a journey to advance and democratize artificial intelligence through open source and open science.

huggingface.co

You can run the smaller models on a modern gaming pc well enough.

If you want to run the larger models you'll need a pretty substantial PC, but they are top notch and avoid any government meddling or data security issues.

I run the QWEN 3.5 Q8_0 model on a PC with 64 GB RAM and a 16 GB AMD graphics card and it's results are excellent and it processes at around 9 tokens/second.

This too. But if you more or less put a ban on AI, that means it's impossible to be a competitive software engineer in today's market without it. It's a requirement you're using agents at this point in your day to day workflow. I think tech savvy people will easily get around it, but effectively it will cause a drain on NYC's tech industry.

 

[FP1201]

This too. But if you more or less put a ban on AI, that means it's impossible to be a competitive software engineer in today's market without it. It's a requirement you're using agents at this point in your day to day workflow. I think tech savvy people will easily get around it, but effectively it will cause a drain on NYC's tech industry.

Think back to the days following 9-11 where governments wanted to know what books you were checking out of Libraries, what Web sites you were visiting, what commentary you were leaving and even passed Laws to allow them to scrutinize the information you were acquiring, what you wanted to learn about....History repeats.

 

[Cooolone]

NY ... The epitome of the Nanny State... Where you only get to live by permission!!! You need permission to do anything, you have no freedom to decide! Everything is codified by law, soon even breathing!

Ridiculous and suffocating! You only realize how much so, once you escape, and get to see the pickle barrel you were in from the outside!

 

[Grimscale]

If this goes through, most people will simply VPN around it who can't leave. Tech companies will effectively leave NYS and it will destroy NYC's economy.

And, predictibly, the State .gov will attempt to ban VPNs (again?).
And internet providers will willingly give you up to them to protect themselves.
And more and more people will leave NY, more companies (who use VPN regularly) will leave NY.

Hard to believe any politician will kill the golden goose, but here we are.

 

[SonOfSun]

And, predictibly, the State .gov will attempt to ban VPNs (again?).
And internet providers will willingly give you up to them to protect themselves.
And more and more people will leave NY, more companies (who use VPN regularly) will leave NY.

Hard to believe any politician will kill the golden goose, but here we are.

NY has never proposed a VPN ban. A few states have, and it didn't go anywhere. As always it's the ignorant that propose the bans. They have absolutely zero understanding of how technology works and what the impacts would be. Entities like banks use the technology to securely transmit data over the internet. Do they think banking details transferred over the Internet in clear text is a good idea? Well, if they support banning VPNs then that's what they are proposing. Bunch of smooth brains up in those chambers. Sometimes I wonder if state governments are really just large special education centers.

 

[SonOfSun]

This too. But if you more or less put a ban on AI, that means it's impossible to be a competitive software engineer in today's market without it. It's a requirement you're using agents at this point in your day to day workflow. I think tech savvy people will easily get around it, but effectively it will cause a drain on NYC's tech industry.

Yes and no. It would create a sub-market in software. Presumably if the US banned AI, then all programs sold would need to be made without it. So everyone would theoretically be on an equal footing.

The reality is that people would "cheat" to gain a competitive advantage. You'd be dumb not to as you know your competitors would be. All it would do is create an underground dark market. Occasionally you'd see an "AI bust", just like drug busts. Once a technology exists that improves efficiency everyone needs to use it to be competitive. Genies stay out of the bottle once released.