All Things Presidential Election 2024

TEOTWAWKI inc.

TEOTWAWKI inc.

.338 Win Mag
Messages
7,538
Reaction score
15,492
Location
Tennessee, U.S.A.
Defilade said:
View attachment 247562
Elon Musk: We Should not have Computers do Voting Tabulations At All

“It’s far too easy to hack a computer, I know how to hack a computer, and Givernment software is the easiest thing to hack… it’s not the best software.

My opinions we should have paper ballots only, and should be in-person voting, with ID…

End of story…”
Click to expand...
While I agree, I also believe the entire election process could be administered fairly and securely on an application like Twitter with the incorporation of a blockchain.

When the clock strikes midnight on election day, all eligible voters can begin a fresh registration process with multi step identity verification, each mining a single token (ballot), and then using that token to cast their vote.

Announcing candidacy, nominating petitions, and campaign contributions could all be handled similarly.

I would even trust Musk (to some degree) to run that system.
 
spat

spat

.950 JDJ
Messages
30,417
Reaction score
64,324
Location
Formerly Geneseo, NY. Now free in AZ
TEOTWAWKI inc. said:
While I agree, I also believe the entire election process could be administered fairly and securely on an application like Twitter with the incorporation of a blockchain.

When the clock strikes midnight on election day, all eligible voters can begin a fresh registration process with multi step identity verification, each mining a single token (ballot), and then using that token to cast their vote.

Announcing candidacy, nominating petitions, and campaign contributions could all be handled similarly.

I would even trust Musk (to some degree) to run that system.
Click to expand...
A fully electronic voting process could be built, but not like that.

It would have to be completely open source, and completely replicateable.

I.e. all the hardware and software is a completely public design.

And all the data is available publicly for free by anyone who cares to download it.

There would be no need for recounts, because anyone who wants can count it, and if they don't get the exact same answer as the official one, then we need to identify which one screwed up.

But, it can't be like mining from a block chain, because that can't be unique to a voter. That's "whoever can throw the most CPUs at it gets the most votes".

But, there is a fundamental problem that cannot be overcome to have a truly secure election.

There is no way, even theoretically, to have both fully auditable votes and secret ballots.

There is a trick that can get close, where any voter could identify if their vote was tampered with, but they wouldn't be able to prove it. If there were any way for them to prove it, then the ballot wouldn't be secret.
 
Last edited:
TEOTWAWKI inc.

TEOTWAWKI inc.

.338 Win Mag
Messages
7,538
Reaction score
15,492
Location
Tennessee, U.S.A.
spat said:
A fully electronic voting process could be built, but not like that.

It would have to be completely open source, and completely replicate.

I.e. all the hardware and software is a completely public design.

And all the data is available publicly for free by anyone who cares to download it.

There would be no need for recounts, because anyone who wants can count it, and if they don't get the exact same answer as the official one, then we need to identify which one screwed up.

But, it can't be like mining from a block chain, because that can't be unique to a voter. That's "whoever can throw the most CPUs at it gets the most votes".

But, there is a fundamental problem that cannot be overcome to have a truly secure election.

You is no way, even theoretically, to have both fully auditable votes and secret ballots.

There is a trick that can get close, where any voter could identify if their vote was tampered with, but they wouldn't be able to prove it. If there were any way for them to prove it, then the ballot wouldn't be secret.
Click to expand...
Why couldn't mining a token from a block chain be unique to each individual voter? It would just represent a unique transaction (verified identity through MFA, proving eligibility to vote).
 
spat

spat

.950 JDJ
Messages
30,417
Reaction score
64,324
Location
Formerly Geneseo, NY. Now free in AZ
TEOTWAWKI inc. said:
Why couldn't mining a token from a block chain be unique to each individual voter? It would just represent a unique transaction (verified identity through MFA, proving eligibility to vote).
Click to expand...
How would you prevent a voter from mining 2 tokens ?

And why couldn't that mechanism be implemented *without* the voter having to do the mining themself ?


Basically, the vast majority of legitimate voters have no idea what mining a token from a block chain is, and would need to outsource that part anyway.

Telling Grandpa that he needs to mine a token to vote, and he'll go out to the garage and grab a pick and shovel.


Blockchain could be used, but the tokens would need to be assigned to voters, there's no way they would be mining them themselves, and I can't think of any reason you'd want them to.
 
masterswimmer

masterswimmer

.450/400 Nitro Ex
Messages
9,934
Reaction score
18,323
Location
Nrth of Mason Dixon
spat said:
Basically, the vast majority of legitimate voters have no idea what mining a token from a block chain is, and would need to outsource that part anyway.

Telling Grandpa that he needs to mine a token to vote, and he'll go out to the garage and grab a pick and shovel.


Me: Hello Spat, nice to meet you. I'm grandpa. I'm too old for a pick and shovel. I'm using dynamite.
Click to expand...
 
Drinkthekoolaid

Drinkthekoolaid

.475 A&M Magnum
U.S. Military
Messages
16,597
Reaction score
29,458
Location
Unfortunately, NY
We are now 2 weeks out. Expect some sketchy shit to happen soon.

I have a few speculative predictions

1- the middle east war starts with Iran before the election.

2- something happens to the Internet/grid on election day or right before throwing enough uncertainty into the process that regardless of who wins the other side won't accept the results.

3- an actual kinetic terror attack
See this link and Afghan National Arrested for Plotting an Election Day Terrorist Attack in the Name of ISIS
I'm assuming there a 0.0% chance this was the only guy that was plotting and no one else in the plot is still loose.
 
Defilade

Defilade

.700 Nitro Express
Messages
26,626
Reaction score
38,282
Location
Elsewhere
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top