NY will just deny permits IMO.
DOJ: Supreme Court Will Legalize AR-15s
- Thread starter Defilade
- Start date
Bustedknees
12-gauge slug (smooth bore)
Will this happen before I die?
All of this will depend on the language of the Justices.
This is something that will NEVER happen.
No matter who is on the court and who controls DC.... NEVER GOING TO HAPPEN>
spat
.950 JDJ
Unless they make state officials personally responsible for violating the 2A it won't matter what else they do.
It needs to be a direct tort with no immunity available for anyone.
Violating someone's 2A rights *should* be legally recognized as a clear and present threat of deadly force, and should be an affirmative defense for anyone treating it accordingly. It isn't, but it should be.
Deplorable Me
.700 Nitro Express
Except in NY, screw NY.
I don’t trust SCOTUS to do the right thing under Chief Justice RINO Roberts,- especially when it comes to granting Cert on 2A, and other cases.
And even when they do take them, he does his best to water them down if we do win them.
No, screw Roberts.
And even when they do take them, he does his best to water them down if we do win them.
No, screw Roberts.
How can the SCOTUS legalize something that is already legal (except in a few communist states)? They are weapons in common use therefore they are already protected. The only thing the court can do is give straight language. “The state nor the federal government has the authority to make laws, rules, regulations to ban or restrict arms based upon action type, accessories, features, caliber, barrel length, type, magazine capacity, political nickname, or color. This would kill the NFA and all state/ federal laws instantly.
Poor choice of words on the part of the DoJ.
But then again, this DoJ has had a history of using poor words (mostly to defend un-constitutional laws).
And This is, after all, just an OPINION. We've seen in the past how anemic this SCOTUS is when it comes to 2A issues.
Until Cert is granted, and un-Constitutional laws slapped down, I can't believe SCOTUS will do their duty anymore.
Mark at the Four Boxes Diner seems fairly "in the know" about SCOTUS issues, and I wish I could believe his rampant optimism that this Court will do what they need to do. But the longer they drag this out the less and less I can believe it.
Anyone waiting on the court to save us from ourselves is smoking crack. The best way to get after this is to stop electing RINOs, Marxist, socialist and democrat politicians. We are in a mess of our own making.
Celt
.450/400 Nitro Ex
Lets say scotus rules that states cant ban them. Ny will respond by saying they are in compliance because they arent banned, they just have to be nuetered. This will require another lawsuit that will take years and millions of dollars to argue that banning features is the same thing. THEN, the state will respond by requiring permits for rifles just like hand guns because scotus said permits were ok already.
Saltwater60
20×102mm Vulcan
Those saying they are already legal so what can they do? The article states throughout the USA so it’s accurate. They are not legalized throughout the USA as designed.
The Supreme Court ultimately will legalize the AR-15 semiautomatic rifle throughout the U.S., according to Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon.
Also, I’m skeptical, but I’d surely welcome it. As for nys not issuing permits I suspect a ruling would likely cover that, but the court has said permitting is ok as long as it’s not too costly or burdensome.
I’m not holding my breath but kavannaugh said this year and now the DOJ is indicating it as well. We will see.
The Supreme Court ultimately will legalize the AR-15 semiautomatic rifle throughout the U.S., according to Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon.
Also, I’m skeptical, but I’d surely welcome it. As for nys not issuing permits I suspect a ruling would likely cover that, but the court has said permitting is ok as long as it’s not too costly or burdensome.
I’m not holding my breath but kavannaugh said this year and now the DOJ is indicating it as well. We will see.
JunkBoxFull
.308 Win
What`s sad is, a few of us are just to old to ever see our rights back, and being able to own again, what we once had. 
Wife is retiring real soon, i just hope i can live long enough to see NYS in my rearview mirror before i`m gone.
I`m not even going to worry about the SCOTUS anymore after seeing what the communists did in NY after NY vs Bruen.
Wife is retiring real soon, i just hope i can live long enough to see NYS in my rearview mirror before i`m gone.
I`m not even going to worry about the SCOTUS anymore after seeing what the communists did in NY after NY vs Bruen.
thughes
.223 Rem
Yep! 30 years after any favorable SCOTUS decision, NY subjects will still be fighting for the same rights that most of us in Free America currently enjoy. Sorry guys.....
dwa12479
.338 Win Mag
Robin
.577 Tyrannosaur.
Um, er, Yeah they will.
Robin
Robin
JunkBoxFull
.308 Win
And then, they killed him
He killed more of them...And then, they killed him