HUGE 2A WIN: New York Gun Ban Declared Unconstitutional Under 2A...

[pshift]

US District Court judge Suddaby finds that NY ban on guns in public housing violates the 2nd Amendment. Mark Smith Four Boxes Diner analyzes the opinion.


We shall see if it holds up and if they rule on other 'off-limits places' as well.

 

[ManualF150]

A decade later, I'm still waiting for the Safe Act to go away... oh, and the CCIA too.

All this stuff makes me yawn.

As far as I'm aware all the laws of the CCIA are still in place for carrying on public and private property along with needing that stupid sign...

 

[Saltwater60]

I’d love to see them challenge this. The Supreme Court has already said you ah e the right to a gun in your home. If they keep pushing then thinks won’t go so well

 

[Dr. Evil]

 

[Acer-m14]

I’d love to see them challenge this. The Supreme Court has already said you ah e the right to a gun in your home. If they keep pushing then thinks won’t go so well

I thought SCOTUS already ruled on this years ago ..



i think they did ...


hell i showed this NY ruling to a co-worker and he still said my landlord can tell me i can't have guns in the home i own ..

WTF ..


some just do not get the message ..

 

[Grimscale]

The Supreme Court has already said you ah e the right to a gun in your home.

And yet, here we are, still having to beg NY's government for permission to exercise what the Supreme Court said was a Right.
And now, we also have to beg to buy semi-auto rifles.

A law passed that contradicts the Constitution should automatically be null and void. one that ALSO contradicts a Supreme Court decision upholding those Rights should automatically result in charges against those members of the government who passed it.

 

[togmaster]

With all these HUGE win's I can hardly contain myself.

 

[Cooolone]

Doesn't matter what the Judicial Rules...

NY does whatever the fuck it wants! It'll just make another unconstitutional law... It doesn't give one fuck about you or your little Rights! When will people get it!?!?

 

[REF]

And yet, here we are, still having to beg NY's government for permission to exercise what the Supreme Court said was a Right.
And now, we also have to beg to buy semi-auto rifles.

A law passed that contradicts the Constitution should automatically be null and void. one that ALSO contradicts a Supreme Court decision upholding those Rights should automatically result in charges against those members of the government who passed it.

Exactly. All this talk from the left with states defying the SC like Texas with the border crossings but nobody is talking about NY blatantly saying fuck you to the SC about shitting on NYers gun rights.

 

[Zerex]

All public housing in the state are ALREADY rife with guns...........all rules in place in other, non public apartments, trying to regulate gun possession, are equally unconstitutional.....

 

[JunkBoxFull]

Yawn....
There is NO win, until ALL gun laws are destroyed.

 

[Acer-m14]

A law passed that contradicts the Constitution should automatically be null and void.

i believe it is ....

“A Law repugnant to the Constitution is void.” With these words written by Chief Justice Marshall, the Supreme Court for the first time declared unconstitutional a law passed by Congress and signed by the President. Nothing stated in the Constitution gave the Court this specific power.

Marbury v. Madison (1803)

EnlargeDownload Link Citation: Show-cause order served on James Madison, Secretary of State, 1802; Records of the Supreme Court of the United States; Record Group 267; National Archives. (The document shows damage from the 1898 fire in the Capitol Building.) View Transcript The decision in this...

www.archives.gov

just all the FFLs and LEO do not want to poke the bear and look the other way .... I guess ..

 

[FP1201]

Since when and do you honestly think the Democrats in control of NY/NYC give a fat-flying-fuck about either the Federal or State Constitution? The BLAC Caucus likely is unaware the State even has a Constitution, and likely has never ready the US Constitution, let alone respecting it.
The Courts have no teeth and the Legislators will do cutesy end-runs around any Ruling that does not support THEIR agenda as supplied by their shadow "Donors" who supply the Legislation they want in exchange for keeping the traitors in Office, for which they greatly enrich their personal fortunes....THEY want a "reset" want Citizens in fear of Criminals, have allowed illegal immigrants in and will empower them to do the bidding of those in Office building their own little warlord syndicate with multitudes of Laws against the Lawful transfer of Guns and Ammunition in an unending onslaught of hurdles, disqualifiers, and restrictions designed to discourage and prohibit arms to people that in any other State would lawfully walk out of a Gun Shop with their purchases...If you don't know, you'd better figure it out quick because it's coming fast.

 

[libertysnake]

Enforcement is endorsement. Let us never forget this.

 

[Mosinitis]

Meaningless gains and huge losses for gun owners in NY.

 

[Acer-m14]

I open carried my gun today in many stores and nothing happened

my zipper was down ..

 

[RooftopKorean]

When will any of these tyrants who constantly violate our constitutional rights be held accountable?

This is the exact reason the head of the NYSP should not be appointed but rather voted for. It's a direct conflict of interest that it is appointed.

I feel like if it was a voted position then the head of the department could/would potentially arrest the governor or other politicians who willfully violate citizens constitutional rights.

 

[Grimscale]

I feel like if it was a voted position then the head of the department could/would potentially arrest the governor or other politicians who willfully violate citizens constitutional rights.

The only reason I disagree is that most voted-in positions end up in fear of losing their job next election.

Why haven't these corrupt and tyrannical politicians been arrested the moment they step foot outside their protected enclave in Albany? Any sheriff has enough evidence to arrest due to these politicians statements and voting history.

When a few members of the NY Legislature end up in a local pokey for rights violations the rest might just sit up and take notice.
Then they will either double-down on their stupidity and try to pass laws to protect themselves or they'll wise up and fix their mess and remember they work at OUR sufferance!

 

[Beerman]

So much winning. I’m getting tired of all the winning.

 

[Saltwater60]

And yet, here we are, still having to beg NY's government for permission to exercise what the Supreme Court said was a Right.
And now, we also have to beg to buy semi-auto rifles.

A law passed that contradicts the Constitution should automatically be null and void. one that ALSO contradicts a Supreme Court decision upholding those Rights should automatically result in charges against those members of the government who passed it.

I’ll add reparations to that since that’s the buzz word of the year.

 

[Saltwater60]

So much winning. I’m getting tired of all the winning.

It’s getting hard to keep up with all the rights we’ve gotten back isn’t it?

 

[fresch]

I open carried my gun today in many stores and nothing happened

my zipper was down ..

Concealed is concealed

 

[nortatoga]

Yup all these Court case's that are going are way are just small nothing-burgers and these 2A groups should just stop because it is up-setting way too many here on the forum!!

 

[Willyone]

Yup all these Court case's that are going are way are just small nothing-burgers and these 2A groups should just stop because it is up-setting way too many here on the forum!! View attachment 226258

Fuck... I've lost track of the latest givith & takith bullshit. I simply CCW depending on my presumed or known safety factor of where I'm going.

 

[ManualF150]

Fuck... I've lost track of the latest givith & takith bullshit. I simply CCW depending on my presumed or known safety factor of where I'm going.

My local pistol permit office pretty much said that in a very round about way..... LOL

 

[Willyone]

My local pistol permit office pretty much said that in a very round about way..... LOL

I don't doubt that.

If I CC say in a mall, bank, restaurant, whatever or wherever I'm not allowed to CC, and get "caught" and have to go up in front of a judge no doubt I'll hear the old "ignorance is no excuse" speech, and I'd expect suffer the consequences. I suppose if that happened, I could ask the judge to inform me of the latest, like todays CC rules & regs. Very good chance a judge wouldn't know the lates and greatest either. Actually I'm not overly concerned about it, but it does take up a bit of space in my menial spec of gray matter

 

[spat]

I don't doubt that.

If I CC say in a mall, bank, restaurant, whatever or wherever I'm not allowed to CC, and get "caught" and have to go up in front of a judge no doubt I'll hear the old "ignorance is no excuse" speech, and I'd expect suffer the consequences. I suppose if that happened, I could ask the judge to inform me of the latest, like todays CC rules & regs. Very good chance a judge wouldn't know the lates and greatest either. Actually I'm not overly concerned about it, but it does take up a bit of space in my menial spec of gray matter

Funny how "ignorance is no excuse" unless you're a government agent, then everything is just an "honest mistake".

 

[FP1201]

I’ll add reparations to that since that’s the buzz word of the year.

Reparations are a manipulative tool the dems keep using: They have no intention of ever passing or fulfilling, and when it doesn't happen, they blame Republicans for it winning in both directions: they keep dumb fucks voting "D" thinking they're going to get something and hating "R" (reverting/insuring) future "D" votes.

 

[S&W Fan]

Reparations are a manipulative tool the dems keep using: They have no intention of ever passing or fulfilling, and when it doesn't happen, they blame Republicans for it winning in both directions: they keep dumb fucks voting "D" thinking they're going to get something and hating "R" (reverting/insuring) future "D" votes.

The diseased mind of a leftist are masters of deception.