The Gun Grenade in the Hands of the Supreme Court
- Thread starter byron
- Start date
BDinPutnam
.475 A&M Magnum
Terrible (and lazy) analysis.
The most likely outcome of the case is that certain of NYC's rules (which only apply to NYC) are struck.
Extra "op-ed as reporting" points for referring to "pro-gun Brett Kavanuagh."
You want to "pull the pin", bring in the open vs concealed carry issue from out west.
The most likely outcome of the case is that certain of NYC's rules (which only apply to NYC) are struck.
Extra "op-ed as reporting" points for referring to "pro-gun Brett Kavanuagh."
You want to "pull the pin", bring in the open vs concealed carry issue from out west.
IrishMick
.44 mag
Totally mis represents the Miller decision.
They're afraid. Good.
kev74
20×102mm Vulcan
There's talk on NYC & NYS rewriting the law to make the case moot and avoid what happened in DC - shall issue.
@Airborneguy is spot on. They're scared.
@Airborneguy is spot on. They're scared.
I've seen that too, but I don't believe they can do that now. Pretty sure the Court can still rule on it. I guess we need a lawyer to chime in on that one. I could ask my friend but he's a super lib and not into discussing gun cases with me lol.
nortatoga
.338 Win Mag
Another article from the New Yorker
Will the Supreme Court Use a New York City Regulation to Strike Down Gun Laws?
Will the Supreme Court Use a New York City Regulation to Strike Down Gun Laws?
@thewheels
.308 Win
"In New York State Rifle & Pistol Assoc., the Second Circuit noted that “we have historically expressed hesitance to import First Amendment principles wholesale into Second Amendment jurisprudence” and “that state regulation of the right to bear arms has always been more robust than analogous regulation of other constitutional rights."
Where in the constitution does the court find license to rule in this manner?
Somebody tell me again how the courts aren't corrupt?
Where in the constitution does the court find license to rule in this manner?
Somebody tell me again how the courts aren't corrupt?
ArmedCorgi
.475 A&M Magnum
That article also shows they are afraid. I also doubt that 60% of Americans want stricter gun control as the article states.
byron
.308 Win
they did not ask me O right they only call libs
Everything that side claims is a lie.
I've been reading every single leftist article I can find regarding this case. They're very afraid. The lefty group I debate with on Facebook is trembling. They've pretty much already decided that the Court will come out swinging, likely codifying a "reciprocity" or even outright nationwide carrying of firearms regardless of permits. That group is mostly made us of prosecutors and defense attorneys, so their fear is based on years of legal training which makes me feel really, really good about this.
Although that is great, I still want my rifles back!
byron
.308 Win
ArmedCorgi
.475 A&M Magnum
Bets on there being another mass shooting right before the case is heard?
Wouldn’t doubt it.
camper4lyfe
.308 Win
NYC gun laws are f'd up. Period. I understand that it requires a license to own ANY firearm within the city, but now it's trying to license to own a firearm at a residences OUTSIDE the city? That's not even a thing, is it? The guy can't get a NYS CCW because he lives in NYC and therefore can't carry outside of NYC.
The "logic" makes my head spin.
The "logic" makes my head spin.
camper4lyfe
.308 Win
That makes me ridiculously giddy. But then I remember I live in NYS, and any optimism is a dangerous thing.
ProgSpear
.338 Win Mag
@ArmedCorgi, I could not like your post, but sadly, I agree that this is a likely scenario, as leftists have demonstrated they will stoop to any action that will foster their ends.
Shadow2
6.5 Creedmoor
The court can still rule on the case because the damage has been done, the right was denied. He would be entitled to get a ruling too sue for damages. In this case lawyer and court fees ect. If your unlawfully arrested state can't change the law to make the arrest legal.
Shadow2
6.5 Creedmoor
BDinPutnam
.475 A&M Magnum
What damages? Monetary damages?
Not how it works generally with rights cases. You seek specific remedies. In this case the city would say "we don't do that anymore" and the court would likely drop hands and say done is done.
Again... It all comes down to the Scrutiny the courts will allow being applied selectively to Rights in convenience standards...
It is, or isn't it, a "Right!"???
If they can codify it, regulate it, smother it on paper, instituting defacto denial by such... Then it should not be allowable by law, ordinance or policy. If you cannot "discriminate" based upon a person's color, religion, sex, or identity, etc., then how are you allowed to discriminate based upon their choice to exercise their 2nd Amendment Rights? Is a convoluted world... Fuck NY!
It is, or isn't it, a "Right!"???
If they can codify it, regulate it, smother it on paper, instituting defacto denial by such... Then it should not be allowable by law, ordinance or policy. If you cannot "discriminate" based upon a person's color, religion, sex, or identity, etc., then how are you allowed to discriminate based upon their choice to exercise their 2nd Amendment Rights? Is a convoluted world... Fuck NY!
Steal2B
.700 Nitro Express
The left is having wet dreams about simultaneously controlling both houses and the Whitehouse to be able to stack the court and exercise their final solution with no legal recourse.
The Court-Packing Threat to the Second Amendment
The Court-Packing Threat to the Second Amendment
Shadow2
6.5 Creedmoor
Last edited:
I shot with one of the plaintiffs yesterday.
What's his feeling about the outcome?
No one really talked about it. He spoke about it at last month’s meeting but I wasn’t there.
HighlandLofts
6.5 Creedmoor
It's not up to the fake libaturd 60% of the people, it's up to judges reading the law and applying it to the case ar hand.
I'm so sick & tired of these fake poles they come up with.
holdover
.475 A&M Magnum
You mean like the Hillary Clinton landslide polls or sierra polls by his majesty the dick head? or CNN Donald Trump has zero chance Polls?
Last edited:
HighlandLofts
6.5 Creedmoor
And the dumbass sheeple believe them.