Tinman
.308 Win
What would be a good price for a mint condition 686+? It has a 3” barrel, original box and paperwork.
S&W 686 plus worth
- Thread starter Tinman
- Start date
JunkBoxFull
.308 Win
Probably around $500 at best for used retail if you want to sell it quicker.
Tinman
.308 Win
Wow, that little? New they are going for over $900
JunkBoxFull
.308 Win
Yup, i know, it sucks. I just bought one a couple months ago brand new for $969. I didn`t like it at all, and looked into getting rid of it for something else, and that was the highest offer i got for mine from several places, brand new, less than 50rds thru it with all the papers and the plastic S&W hard case with it.
If you can find a buyer for more, take it. Try listing it in here in the classifieds and see what people say, or if someone bites.
Deplorable Me
.700 Nitro Express
Which grips? The stock rubber grips are preferred, the 3-5-7 black grips run small.
Gun broker has a few listings for between $650 and 800
Yeah , no, don't listen to that $500 stuff.
Mint condition with box and paperwork would also be on the high end.
What is the 686-* number (the dash number) ? Does it have the external lock ?
Mint condition with box and paperwork would also be on the high end.
What is the 686-* number (the dash number) ? Does it have the external lock ?
Tinman
.308 Win
Has the external lock. Both wood grips and rubber. Round count is exactly 7. Has been a safe queen. Model 686-6
Last edited:
Retail store is always going to pay about 50% of list value then a good shop will trum it around for maybe 100 more or else no one would buy it. Case in point I am going to be purchasing a used HK USP 45 from my LGS. They want $700 for it. The "blue book" value ranges from $800-$1200 for a used one and this particular example is in excellent condition so value would ve closer to tge 1200 end. However at 1200 I'd rather just drop a couple hundred more in a new one.
If OP needs top dollar then selling it on Gunbroker or whichever is the only option.
Or try the listings here.
700 sounds like a good price to go for.
If OP needs top dollar then selling it on Gunbroker or whichever is the only option.
Or try the listings here.
700 sounds like a good price to go for.
Last edited:
Does it have a fluted or unfluted cylinder. That makes a difference to some buyers as well. I’d say in excellent condition with the box and docs you should be able to get $750 or maybe more for it on the secondary market. Selling it to a shop will most certainly get you much less.
Tinman
.308 Win
Thanks for all of your input. A member contacted me and it has sold.
Bustedknees
12-gauge slug (smooth bore)
Any chance said buyer has the initials S&W??
Robin
.577 Tyrannosaur.
4"-5" barrel I probably would have grabbed it.
Robin
Robin
Tinman
.308 Win
Nope
Unfortunately I had to ( very reluctantly ) let it get away from me. I was sorely tempted though! My gun slush fund is currently depleted due to two lever gun purchases a couple of weeks ago.
I’m actually looking for a 3” barreled 686 + with the unfluted cylinder.
How about a 3" 586 that goes click more than bang?
Sorry to hear that you’re still having issues with your carry comp.
Sadly, S&W ‘s quality control is nothing like it used to be.
3rd trip back to the factory now. Let's hope this time is the charm.
Saltwater60
20×102mm Vulcan
I’d be asking them to give you a new one. It’s a revolver so it shouldn’t be that hard.
Indeed. I don't think I could sell such a gun in good conscience so it seems I am stuck with it. If S&W cannot fix it the only other think I can think of is sending it to TK custom to have it inspected and all internals replaced with superior parts. This is extremely expensive however.
They essentially have already done that. The last time they "replaced barrel cylinder and frame" different serial # on the frame of course and I can only construe that is internal code speak for "new gun". However S&W's new revolver quality is so incredibly poor I don't think simply replacing it would help. It seem getting a good new manufacture S&W revolver is now tge exception to the rule.
They'd have to give me a whole batch of 'em for me to hand pick the good one among them, if any, at this point.
Robin
.577 Tyrannosaur.
Man, that sucks! Hard to believe S&W hasn't dealt with this in a proper manner. I guess the older I get the more I live in the past, tho somethings should be timeless.
Robin
Robin
Bustedknees
12-gauge slug (smooth bore)
Have they been covering shipping cost?
I'd ask for a complete refund at this point.
I'd ask for a complete refund at this point.
Deplorable Me
.700 Nitro Express
Figured it might have been you or KEV74 . Nice snag !
Deplorable Me
.700 Nitro Express
It looked brand new. Luster shine. Tinman must of used his wife's toothbrush for a week polishing it.
Oh sure, Rub it in why don’t you.
Deplorable Me
.700 Nitro Express
I have a lustful love affair for stainless revolvers.Oh sure, Rub it in why don’t you.
Tinman
.308 Win
I just ordered a new Colt Kodiak. .44 mag. 4 1/4” barrel. Should be here by Saturday.
We’ll definitely need to see some gun pics of that one !