2A Lawsuits and their progress we have here in NY

drowhawk

drowhawk

.44 mag
Messages
974
Reaction score
1,403
Location
Livingston
Phazer said:
The political tide ALWAYS shifts. Sometimes slowly. Frequently against us. But it always shifts.
Click to expand...
As technology progresses, we become less and less free. Man as been more free under more oppressive regimes simply by nature of technology. They (the govt) are everywhere at once now.

Just sucks to be completely SOL with no chance of it getting better unless I leave NY.
 
M

m1_ping

9mm
Messages
51
Reaction score
123
Location
Oneida County
Saltwater60 said:
The decision is only on the TRO correct?
Im a bit worried but I have a good feeling about this one for some reason. I’m usually very skeptical, but I think he will grant it. Of course this is just a feeling but the Virginia ruling and Suddaby’s past comments on this have to mean something. I guess we will see at some point soon.
Click to expand...
Correct. This is only for the TRO.
 
Last edited:
Beerman

Beerman

6.5 Creedmoor
Messages
2,310
Reaction score
3,506
Location
Deep in the Adirondacks
CaliberPlus said:
Judge is stalling, not giving a decision. Excuse my attitude, I am not surprised. And this is on a TRO, not Injuunction. If he truly believed the law was unconstitutional, a complete Injunction should have been given. I would love to be wrong on this one but I think I called it earlier and it was not positive.
Click to expand...
Don’t be so moody, Jan. It’s gonna be ok. Last time this judge heard this case (sort of) he dismissed it on standing, and still issued a 78 page pile of helpful info on how to move forward. Do you really think he was just going up smack his little mallet on his coffee coaster and yell, “Screw you, crappy Kathy! It’s all shit down!”????? He needs some time to write up his TRO in such a way as to thwart the State’s immediate appeal the the 2nd Circuit, (which will probably happen, and will be heard there even while the district court is still arguing the original case.) It’s a real mess, and it’s neither quick nor easy to be resolved.
 
Drinkthekoolaid

Drinkthekoolaid

.475 A&M Magnum
U.S. Military
Messages
17,560
Reaction score
31,375
Location
Unfortunately, NY
drowhawk said:
Lmfao cant believe you are all still talking about this. We got punished. Get over it. We will NEVER have less infringements; only more. Hochul said flat out she is ready to go back to muskets. And you guys thought she was bluffing!

The more noise we make, the more punishment will come down from the state. Period.
Click to expand...


Thank you sir may I have another!
 
US RIFLE M1A

US RIFLE M1A

.45 acp
Messages
362
Reaction score
886
Location
PA/NY Border in NEPA
Beerman said:
Don’t be so moody, Jan. It’s gonna be ok. Last time this judge heard this case (sort of) he dismissed it on standing, and still issued a 78 page pile of helpful info on how to move forward. Do you really think he was just going up smack his little mallet on his coffee coaster and yell, “Screw you, crappy Kathy! It’s all shit down!”????? He needs some time to write up his TRO in such a way as to thwart the State’s immediate appeal the the 2nd Circuit, (which will probably happen, and will be heard there even while the district court is still arguing the original case.) It’s a real mess, and it’s neither quick nor easy to be resolved.
Click to expand...
This is the best summary of the situation. This judge is two things: anti CCIA and very thorough.
 
C

CaliberPlus

.45 acp
Messages
441
Reaction score
820
Location
Mannsville, NY
Not moody, realistic. I have lived in this state my whole life. I have heard for how many years about how the SAFE Act will be overturned. Every time I sell an AR I think, yeah, SAFE ACT. Like I said, I hope I am wrong...........(Swap out the thirty round mag with a ten, pin that mag. Cannot order a standard Hellcat gotta wait for a ten round mag and on and on.)

Just remember the CCIA is only one law. There are lots more that infringe.
 
Acer-m14

Acer-m14

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
35,986
Reaction score
38,605
Location
Livingston
hope the judge puts in his decision.. that the state must pass a 12 panel drug test and a Psych Evaluation to appeal it .. :ROFL: :ROFL: :ROFL:
 
R

RBean

.40 S&W
Messages
208
Reaction score
674
Location
Brooklyn, NY
Having practiced law for almost 50 yrs and handled five gun cases in NY and won four, I think this case is about as sure a thing you can get in litigation. Granted, you never know for sure what a court or judge will do. But the Breun decision is clear, J. Thomas headed off most of the BS that NY's attorney is putting out. I almost feel sorry for the guy. He has to defend an indefensible position. The judge has already found most of the provisions of the new law unconstitutional. (Because they are). He put that in a written decision filed with the court on ECF and published. He is not going to reverse himself. There is no question about standing. The only question is how far he will go and if he will stay his decision pending an appeal. If he issues an injunction and the state authorities ignore it, will he send out the US Marshalls to arrest the governor, AG, State Police Chief etc and hold them contempt and in custody until they comply? He has the authority and power to do so.
 
Acer-m14

Acer-m14

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
35,986
Reaction score
38,605
Location
Livingston
RBean said:
The only question is how far he will go and if he will stay his decision pending an appeal. If he issues an injunction and the state authorities ignore it, will he send out the US Marshalls to arrest the governor, AG, State Police Chief etc and hold them contempt and in custody until they comply? He has the authority and power to do so.
Click to expand...

and that is the big Question ..

Welcome back Bean
 
C

CaliberPlus

.45 acp
Messages
441
Reaction score
820
Location
Mannsville, NY
RBean, care to postulate on the other ten horrible laws? Also, do you practice in NY? It is tough to find a lawyer that has any concept of the gun laws. At least that is what I have found.
 
tirwin1

tirwin1

.577 Tyrannosaur.
Messages
20,512
Reaction score
57,661
Location
rochester
RBean said:
The only question is how far he will go and if he will stay his decision pending an appeal. If he issues an injunction and the state authorities ignore it, will he send out the US Marshalls to arrest the governor, AG, State Police Chief etc and hold them contempt and in custody until they comply? He has the authority and power to do so.
Click to expand...
Never going to happen.
 
R

RBean

.40 S&W
Messages
208
Reaction score
674
Location
Brooklyn, NY
CaliberPlus, Yes I practice is NY but am trying to retire. Only two cases left (not gun cases). There is a lawyer I can recommend re gun cases. They have gotten a lot easier since Buren. And tirwin1, your are right, the judge could do it, but not going to happen. I agree.

I think in view of Buren the SAFE ACT is in serious trouble. No such law in history and tradition outlawing a class of arms. In fact I think the 1934 Firearms may be in trouble.
 
Saltwater60

Saltwater60

20×102mm Vulcan
Messages
38,597
Reaction score
43,003
Location
Western NY
RBean said:
CaliberPlus, Yes I practice is NY but am trying to retire. Only two cases left (not gun cases). There is a lawyer I can recommend re gun cases. They have gotten a lot easier since Buren. And tirwin1, your are right, the judge could do it, but not going to happen. I agree.

I think in view of Buren the SAFE ACT is in serious trouble. No such law in history and tradition outlawing a class of arms. In fact I think the 1934 Firearms may be in trouble.
Click to expand...
Good. I have always wanted a Tommy Gun.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top